News Intelligence Analysis
The New, Unabashed McCarthyism:
A Review of Treason: Liberal Treachery From The Cold War To The War On Terrorism
Originally published by Findlaw.com
By MARK S. ZAID
Senator Joseph McCarthy, a patriotic hero? Liberals all treasonous villains? First Lady, now Senator, Hillary Clinton's cries of a "right wing conspiracy," move over. That one statement for which Senator Clinton has been vilified for time immemorial by conservatives pales in comparison to the liberal conspiracy to betray the United States that is identified by Ann Coulter in her latest political diatribe, Treason: Liberal Treachery From The Cold War To The War On Terrorism.
Coulter's new book asserts that liberals have been wrong on every foreign policy issue for the last fifty years, and that at least since the start of the Cold War they have "contained, appeased, and retreated, often sacrificing America's best interests and security." Her re-examination of the lives of Senator Joseph McCarthy, Whittaker Chambers, Alger Hiss and every Democratic president since Truman will shock anyone to the left of Attila the Hun.
Among her astonishing conclusions:
Coulter's Failure to Define The Straw Man She Attacks
Who are these evil liberals, exactly? In her book, Coulter declines to provide a definition or distinguish liberals from "the Left". In televised appearances Coulter has boasted clearly that liberals are the Democratic Party and its members, every single one of them. Coulter's theory, therefore, runs into some historical anomalies.
For example, both Ronald Reagan and Strom Thurmond, two darlings of the Republican Party, were Democrats until 1962 and 1964, respectively - well into the Cold War period she discusses. Even ardent Republican Jeanne Kirkpatrick, the former U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations, was a Democrat until late into the Carter Administration.
Glorifying Senator Joseph McCarthy's Abuses
Coulter's analysis - some would deem it revisionist history - of Senator McCarthy and his escapades will be startling to most. She contends, amazingly, that "[t]he myth of 'McCarthyism' is the greatest Orwellian fraud of our times. The portrayal of Senator Joe McCarthy as a wild-eyed demagogue destroying innocent lives is sheer liberal hobgoblinism."
As Coulter announced to millions on Good Morning America, "I really just have to ask people to hit the 'delete' button on everything you think you know about McCarthy, because it was a huge liberal myth. It was created to, to hide the left's collaboration with a regime as evil as the Nazis."
Apparently Coulter believes with all her heart that "[w]hat the country needed was Joe McCarthy." Such a comment seems akin to the now-infamous misstatement of former Senator Majority Leader Trent Lott when he suggested the nation would have been better off had it elected segregationist Senator Thurmond (by the way, then still a Democrat) president in 1948.
Coulter claims vast evidence supports her conclusion that McCarthy was right on the mark. She cites to the 1995 release of the Vernona papers, which were created through a top secret U.S. Signals Intelligence effort to collect and decrypt the text of Soviet KGB and GRU messages from 1943 to 1980.
Indeed, the Vernona messages do confirm that Soviet spies operated in the United States, as Senator McCarthy decried. But many respected historians who have researched the documents, such as Professor Athan Theoharis, have pointed out that the information can also be read to seriously undermine the contention that the "red scare" of the 1940s and 50s invigorated by Senator McCarthy (and now Coulter) was justified.
According to Theoharis's book Chasing Spies: How the FBI Failed in Counterintelligence But Promoted the Politics of McCarthyism in the Cold War Years, Vernona reveals that the government's culture of suspicion and blacklists helped fuel McCarthyism's beliefs rather than vindicate his allegations.
Criticism of Coulter and her Book Abound
Coulter's book endlessly rambles and repeats itself, and continually makes illogical leaps and bounds. Her writing is wearying to both the eyes and mind of any reader not possessed by the same vitriolic hatred of these undefined liberals. She appears to operate on the principle that a falsehood or argument repeated often enough will ultimately be accepted as the truth.
Criticism of Coulter's book has been widespread among book reviews and editorials. In fact, it extends beyond the contents of her book and to her personally, many of which might be considered unfair or certainly irrelevant. Among them: "Lethally blond," (David Carr in The New York Times); a "right-wing telebimbo," (Alex Beam of the Boston Globe); a "sex kitten" with "long, blond peekaboo hair" and "Joe McCarthy in a little black dress" (Kevin Horrigan of the St. Louis Post Dispatch); and "a rail-thin, chain-smoking, hard-drinking, big-eyed leggy blonde who winkingly serves up X-rated ideological smut on liberals." (Sam Tanenhaus in Slate).
To be fair, Coulter, who sprung to public fame in 1996 as a conservative MSNBC legal pundit, is no intellectual lightweight. A former federal judicial law clerk, congressional staffer for Senator Spencer Abraham and constitutional attorney, Coulter was even named in a controversial article as one of the top 100 public intellectuals in 2001, by respected federal jurist Richard Posner.
Although Coulter does identify many issues deserving of legitimate debate and historical scholarship, this book is evidence of neither. Instead of a sound, reasoned discussion of the issues, there is largely only anger and rhetoric.
Coulter's Baleful and Growing Influence
Her controversial writings have caused many to seriously question whether she is a positive or negative influence within the Republican Party. Although even Conservative intellectuals have denounced her book, there is no mistaking her growing influence. She continues to inspire many on the Right - particularly young women who see Coulter as a dynamic leadership figure, one with independence and high-profile power, in an organization where they are a definite minority.
It is hard to say what is scarier, the text within Coulter's book or that those in the United States are actually buying and reading it as a serious work. Ironically, Coulter attacks free speech as the premise for "those canny liberals ... to justify their wacko ideas, and "a one-way ratchet for traitors." Of course, the First Amendment seems to work well for both liberals and conservatives, including and especially Coulter herself who is certainly smiling all the way down to her bank to deposit her many royalty checks.
Copyright © 1994-2003 FindLaw
Do you want to know how
to detect evil? Buy these
We give Scott Pecks book, The People of the Lie, a five star rating. It teaches the reader how to detect evil. If you havent read it--read it now. Give it as a gift. Scott Peck tries to find a way to heal human evil. The book is really a journey through his cases as a psychiatrist where he encountered an inexplicable disease that only human love can reach, but which repells the love that seeks to heal it. Its frightening as he shows how ordinary and common place evil is. It sits in our churches on the pews where upright citizens hide behind a mask of piety. It pours from mouths that lie without constraint. Scott Pecks book was written for todays world. It helps us to understand why we are catching glimpses of a dark age that could engulf us.
The Lost Book of Wisdom by K.V. Yurica is a book were prejudiced about. (The publisher of this web site is the author.) Its a book thats off the main stream scale of measuring things. Most Americans wont like it unless theyre into literature, poetry, and the excitement of discovering an ancient world where seers explained how to discover a lie, how to know a true prophet from a false one. Its on ancient science, on knowledge, logic and investigation. It talks about fools, evil and transcendence. It was written long before George W. Bush entered the White House, but it discusses psychological and emotional health as opposed to the Machiavellian rule of today. We think some of you will love it--especially those acquainted with Kahlil Gibran's The Prophet.
These books are available at our favorite bookstore--which just happens to be open. It's an old fashioned sort of place with real people standing on wooden floors. One can sip a mocha and listen to the sounds of a folk singer drifting through the open doors. We like the owners too. Theyre there almost all the time--Saturdays, Sundays--too. Theyll pack these books in a box for you and ship it out and have it delivered to your door. Just click on the book covers--and youll go directly to your book. Village Books will take over from there. Theyll make your purchase a pleasure.
If you prefer making your purchases through the webs largest book store, weve anticipated your need and have prepared this link to the home page of Amazon.com. If you have the time and a good eye for bargains, youll find them there, in the middle of Amazons quaint clutter. One can almost smell the dust trying to settle down after the swish and swosh of the fast paced deals. Just click on the little ad below and youll be there in a moment. Then type in the title of this book in the little search box. Click on Go and walla!
The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. Yet it requires knowledge and constancy. We recommend that you add these books to your library on the theory that we must know our enemies. We must know why Machiavelli's teachings threaten America's democracy and freedom. Ask yourself, "How can people vote intelligently on issues based upon false information?" Lies attack the heart of a democratic society. Understand why you must oppose Machiavellian methods with every fiber in your being.
The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli in Paperback click on the cover
The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli in Hardback
Translated by Harvey Clafin Mansfield, Jr.
Thoughts on Machiavelli, by Leo Strauss Trade Paperback
Michael Ledeen, Machiavelli on Modern Leadership, for
Trade Paperbackclick here or on the cover.
Also available in Hardcover: click here.
The War Against the Terror Masters
Michael Ledeen, click here for the
War Against The Terror Masters
also available in Hardcover click here.
Neoconservatism: The Autobiography
of an Idea by Irving Kristol. This is the
Trade Paperback cover. Check for its
availability at the store.
Neo-Conservatism: The Autobiography
of an Idea by Irving Kristol, Hardback
If you prefer making your purchase through the web's largest book store, we've anticipated your need and have prepared this link to the home page of Amazon.com. If you have the time and a good eye for bargains, you'll find them there, in the middle of Amazon's quaint clutter. One can almost smell the dust trying to settle down after the swish and swosh of the fast paced deals. Just click on the little ad below and you'll be there in a moment:
Back to The Yurica Report Home Page
Copyright © 2003 Yurica Report. All rights reserved.