News Intelligence Analysis
Who Tried To Bribe Rep. Smith?
Stop protecting him, Congressman.
By Timothy Noah
Posted Monday, Dec. 1, 2003, at 3:17 PM PT
Rep. Nick Smith, R-Mich., says that sometime late Nov. 21 or early in the morning Nov. 22, somebody on the House floor threatened to redirect campaign funds away from his son Brad, who is running to succeed him, if he didn't support the Medicare prescription bill. This according to the Associated Press. Robert Novak further reports,
On the House floor, Nick Smith was told business interests would give his son $100,000 in return for his father's vote. When he still declined, fellow Republican House members told him they would make sure Brad Smith never came to Congress. After Nick Smith voted no and the bill passed, [Rep.] Duke Cunningham of California and other Republicans taunted him that his son was dead meat.
Speaking through Chief of Staff Kurt Schmautz, Smith assured Chatterbox that Novak's account is "basically accurate." That means Smith was an eyewitness to a federal crime. United States Code, Title 18, Section 201, "Bribery of public officials and witnesses," states that under federal law, a person commits bribery if he
"directly or indirectly, corruptly gives, offers or promises anything of value to any public official or person who has been selected to be a public official, or offers or promises any public official or any person who has been selected to be a public official to give anything of value to any other person or entity [italics Chatterbox's], with intent to influence any official act. "
Promising to direct $100,000 to Rep. Smith's son's campaign clearly meets the legal definition of bribery. The only question, then, is who to prosecute. The AP had Smith attributing threats to support his son's opponent to "House GOP leaders," but that was a paraphrase, and it is possible Smith meant someone else when he spoke of an actual offer of $100,000. We know House Speaker Dennis Hastert spent a lot of time that night trying to win over Smith. The trade publication CongressDaily spotted Hastert around 4 a.m., about an hour into the extended Medicare roll call, placing his arm around Smith and gesturing. Twenty minutes later, CongressDaily saw Hastert work Smith over again, this time with Health and Human Services Secretary Tommy Thompson. At 5:30 a.m., with less than half an hour left until the final tally, CongressDaily saw Hastert and Thompson give it one final try. The Washington Post's David Broder, in his Nov. 23 column, wrote that House aides "recounted that Hastert said Smith's help was vital to the party and the presidenta fitting gift at the end of a long careerand suggested it would also help Smith's son, who plans to run for the seat." That's pretty close to Novak's version.
But according to Hastert spokesman John Feehery (as quoted by the AP), Hastert merely said "that a vote on this would help him and help his son because it would be a popular vote." Ordinarily, Chatterbox would consider that a laughably weak denial. But Feehery told Chatterbox that Smith had personally assured the speaker that he wasn't the individual he'd complained about. Schmautz, Smith's chief of staff, said Smith had further clarified that the perpetrator not only wasn't Hastert; it wasn't Thompson or House Majority Leader Tom "the Hammer" DeLay, either.
Obviously Smith doesn't want to alienate the GOP establishment by hurling criminal accusations at whoever this phantom bribe-giver may be. But it's a little late for that. If Smith witnessed an attempted bribery, he has an obligation as a citizenand even more so, as member of Congressto make that person's identity known to law enforcement officials. Marc Miller, a Washington attorney who advises clients on ethics issues, told Chatterbox that what Novak described not only looked like "a slam-dunk violation of the bribery law" but probably also included "a smorgasbord of other criminal violations." Rep. Smith, Miller said, "should really be sharing the specifics with the Justice Department."
So, Congressman. Enough with the guessing games. Who tried to bribe you?
[Update, Dec. 2: In a Nov. 28 commentary in the Lenawee (Michigan) Connection, Rep. Smith himself made reference to "bribes and special deals" that "were offered to convince members to vote yes," though he shed little further light on who, his own case, the perpetrator or perpetrators were:
Other members [i.e., not Hastert] and groups made offers of extensive financial campaign support and endorsements for my son, Brad, who is running for my seat. They also made threats of working against Brad if I voted no.
If the Bush Justice department hasn't made inquiries about this yet, it isn't doing its job.
Timothy Noah writes "Chatterbox" for Slate.
Article URL: http://slate.msn.com/id/2091787/
Send a letter
to the editor
about this article
The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. Yet it requires knowledge and constancy. We recommend that you add these books to your library on the theory that we must know our enemies. We must know why Machiavelli's teachings threaten America's democracy and freedom. Ask yourself, "How can people vote intelligently on issues based upon false information?" Lies attack the heart of a democratic society. Understand why you must oppose Machiavellian methods with every fiber in your being.
The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli in Paperback click on the cover
The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli in Hardback
Translated by Harvey Clafin Mansfield, Jr.
Thoughts on Machiavelli, by Leo Strauss Trade Paperback
Michael Ledeen, Machiavelli on Modern Leadership, for
Trade Paperbackclick here or on the cover.
Also available in Hardcover: click here.
The War Against the Terror Masters
Michael Ledeen, click here for the
War Against The Terror Masters
also available in Hardcover click here.
Neoconservatism: The Autobiography
of an Idea by Irving Kristol. This is the
Trade Paperback cover. Check for its
availability at the store.
Neo-Conservatism: The Autobiography
of an Idea by Irving Kristol, Hardback
If you prefer making your purchase through the web's largest book store, we've anticipated your need and have prepared this link to the home page of Amazon.com. If you have the time and a good eye for bargains, you'll find them there, in the middle of Amazon's quaint clutter. One can almost smell the dust trying to settle down after the swish and swosh of the fast paced deals. Just click on the little ad below and you'll be there in a moment:
Back to YURICA REPORT Copyright © 2003 Yurica Report. All rights reserved.