News Intelligence Analysis
'Pulpit Freedom Sunday'
Former IRS Officials File a Complaint
Against Christian Lawyers
Monday, September 8, 2008 3:10 AM
By Meredith Heagney
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
Three former Internal Revenue Service executives plan to file a complaint today against a coalition of Christian lawyers who they say are unethically encouraging pastors nationwide to talk about political candidates from the pulpit.
The complainants, including a former IRS commissioner, are challenging the Alliance Defense Fund for organizing Pulpit Freedom Sunday, set for Sept. 28. On that day, pastors have been asked to challenge IRS codes that bar tax-exempt charities such as churches from endorsing political candidates.
The Alliance Defense Fund, which champions conservative Christian causes, employs 40 attorneys and has trained 1,200 more.
"We believe the project of encouraging, of counseling, of assisting large numbers of churches to violate the tax law is a threat to the integrity of the tax system," said Marcus Owens, who was director of the IRS Exempt Organizations Division for 10 years.
A group of 40 central Ohio religious leaders also plans to file a complaint today asking the IRS to shut down Pulpit Freedom Sunday in advance and to investigate the Alliance Defense Fund to see whether it has engaged in political or illegal activities that would compromise its tax-exempt status.
The complaint also asks the IRS to deny tax deductions and benefits to donors and organizations that knowingly contributed to the pulpit initiative.
The pastors filing the complaint include the Rev. Bob Molsberry, conference minister of the Ohio Conference of the United Church of Christ, the Rev. Rebecca Tollefson, executive director of the Ohio Council of Churches, and Rabbi Harold Berman of Congregation Tifereth Israel.
The former IRS executives, working for the Washington tax-law firm Caplin and Drysdale, are filing the complaint as a matter of principle, Owens said. The other complainants are Mortimer Caplin, who was IRS commissioner under President Kennedy, and Cono Namorato, who formerly directed the IRS' Office of Professional Responsibility.
Alliance Defense Fund lawyers could be sanctioned with a broad range of penalties, from a warning to being barred from practice before the IRS, Owens said.
The Alliance Defense Fund, based in Scottsdale, Ariz., calls itself a "legal ministry." Most of its cases involve the First Amendment rights of Christians, although it also litigates cases against abortion, euthanasia and same-sex marriage.
The group is trying to attract an IRS investigation at each participating church. Congregations would then sue the IRS while being represented by the Alliance Defense Fund. The goal is to get the prohibition against political endorsements declared unconstitutional, said Erik Stanley, the group's senior legal counsel.
About 35 churches had signed on as of last week, and they have been advised of the risks, he said.
Churches that violate IRS code could lose their tax-exempt status, but such a punishment is extremely rare. Since 1954, when federal law was changed to prohibit nonprofit organizations from endorsing political candidates, only one church has even lost its tax-exempt letter ruling, which simply recognizes the church as a nonprofit.
In that case, the Church at Pierce Creek in New York published full-page advertisements in USA Today opposing Bill Clinton for president in 1992. The IRS revoked the church's letter ruling, but the church retained its tax exemption.
Unlike other nonprofits, churches do not need the letter under the tax code, and losing it does not affect their tax-exempt status. However, some churches request it from the IRS as a convenience in case anyone questions their nonprofit status.
Still, the IRS commonly audits churches after complaints, which is an expensive and time-consuming process for the congregations, Owens said. The agency can levy an excise tax for violations, which it prefers to do rather than revoke a tax exemption, he said.
Before 1954, it was commonplace for pastors to speak for or against candidates, Stanley said. He said the IRS is denying preachers' right to free speech and free exercise of religion.
"Politicians didn't get a free pass from moral scrutiny, and they shouldn't get a free pass now," he said. "The Bible has a lot to say about politicians, about certain candidates."
The pastors filing the IRS complaint say they're concerned about churches becoming extensions of political campaigns and worry that pastors or religions could gain political influence by supporting a winning candidate.
In 2006, largely the same group of pastors filed a complaint against the Rev. Rod Parsley of World Harvest Church and the Rev. Russell Johnson, then of Fairfield Christian Church. That complaint said the pastors should forfeit their tax-exempt status because they openly campaigned for Republican gubernatorial nominee J. Kenneth Blackwell.
An IRS spokesman in Ohio didn't return calls last week seeking comment on the outcome of that complaint. A national spokesman for the agency said the IRS generally doesn't comment on investigations.
Send a letter to the editor about this Article
Outing Creeping Dominionism
A Response to an Evangelicals Attack
By Katherine Yurica
Katherine Yurica digs into the Dominionism
movement and exposes the true nature of the
doctrine millions of American Christians have
taken to heart. For the first time, she introduces
her readers to the man who is credited with
writing and inspiring the religious doctrines that
provided a new theological basis for regressive
economics and politics that would counter
traditional Christian progressive thought. One
man and his followers have turned not only
Christianity upside-down, but the future of America
is at stake. It was the insertion of free enterprise
capitalism onto the fabric of the scriptures that
enabled a small group of men to convert Christianity
into a tool that serves the purposes of regressive
conservatism. It is at once alarming and revealing
of the ingenuity and source of power behind the
spreading acceptance of dominionism. In fact, the
combining of conservative economics with edicts
that appear to be out of the mouth of God, may be
seen as one of the most brilliant and powerful
political concepts ever written. The man who
founded Dominionism has empowered the greedy
as no man has ever done: hes made greed a virtue!
Directory on the Rise of Christian Dominionism Strategies, Communication and Propanda Techniques Directory on Religious Trends
This article is copyrighted material, the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Back to The Yurica Report Home Page
Copyright © 2008 Yurica Report. All rights reserved.