News Intelligence Analysis
Scalia Jeers Fans of 'Living'
Charter
Published February 15, 2006
PONCE, Puerto Rico (AP) -- People who think the Constitution
would break if it didn't change with society are "idiots,"
U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia says.
In a speech Monday sponsored by the conservative Federalist Society,
Justice Scalia defended his long-held belief in sticking to the
plain text of the Constitution "as it was originally written
and intended."
"Scalia does have a philosophy; it's called originalism.
That's what prevents him from doing the things he would like
to do," Justice Scalia told more than 100 politicians and
lawyers from this U.S. island territory.
He said that, according to his judicial philosophy, there can
be no room for personal, political or religious beliefs.
Justice Scalia criticized those who believe in what he called
the "living Constitution."
"That's the argument of flexibility, and it goes something
like this: The Constitution is over 200 years old, and societies
change. It has to change with society, like a living organism,
or it will become brittle and break.
"But you would have to be an idiot to believe that,"
Justice Scalia said. "The Constitution is not a living organism;
it is a legal document. It says something and doesn't say other
things."
Proponents of the living Constitution want matters to be decided
"not by the people, but by the justices of the Supreme Court."
"They are not looking for legal flexibility; they are looking
for rigidity. Whether it's the right to abortion or the right
to homosexual activity, they want that right to be embedded from
coast to coast and to be unchangeable," he said.
Justice Scalia was invited to Puerto Rico by the Federalist Society
for Law and Public Policy Studies. The organization was founded
in 1982 as a debating society by students who thought professors
at the top law schools were too liberal.
Copyright © 2006 News World Communications, Inc. All rights reserved.
Scalia Has Harsh Words for
Those Who Believe in 'Living Constitution'
By
Jonathan Ewing
The Associated Press
02-15-2006
People who believe the Constitution would break if it didn't change with society are "idiots," U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia says.
In a speech in Puerto Rico Monday sponsored by the conservative Federalist Society, Scalia defended his long-held belief in sticking to the plain text of the Constitution "as it was originally written and intended."
"Scalia does have a philosophy, it's called originalism," he said. "That's what prevents him from doing the things he would like to do," he told more than 100 politicians and lawyers from this U.S. island territory.
According to his judicial philosophy, he said, there can be no room for personal, political or religious beliefs.
Scalia criticized those who believe in what he called the "living Constitution."
"That's the argument of flexibility and it goes something like this: The Constitution is over 200 years old and societies change. It has to change with society, like a living organism, or it will become brittle and break."
"But you would have to be an idiot to believe that," Scalia said. "The Constitution is not a living organism, it is a legal document. It says something and doesn't say other things."
Proponents of the living constitution want matters to be decided "not by the people, but by the justices of the Supreme Court."
"They are not looking for legal flexibility, they are looking for rigidity, whether it's the right to abortion or the right to homosexual activity, they want that right to be embedded from coast to coast and to be unchangeable," he said.
Scalia was invited to Puerto Rico by the Federalist Society for Law and Public Policy Studies. The organization was founded in 1982 as a debating society by students who believed professors at the top law schools were too liberal. Conservatives and libertarians mainly make up the 35,000 members.
Copyright 2006 Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
Send a letter
to the editor
about
this article
Directory of Law and Legal Issues
Battle for the Judiciary Directory
Back to The Yurica Report Home Page
Copyright © 2006 Yurica Report. All rights reserved.